- Trim the wick to
- 5mm Living Light; NCA says ¼ inch
- Normal flame, 30cl jar
- 30–35mm Candle Shack's figure
- Mushrooming is
- Unburnt carbon Too much fuel, not enough air
- Faulty wick?
- CGA applies Repair, replace or refund
Which wick problem have you got?
Match what you can see to the row below. Four of the five are fixed at home with a wick trimmer or a paper towel. The fifth, a wick that's simply too small for the jar, can't be fixed by you. That one is a fault in how the candle was made.
| What you see | What's happening | Fix it at home | Maker's fault? |
|---|---|---|---|
| A black blob on the tip of the wick (mushrooming) | Carbon builds up because the wick is drawing more fuel than the flame can burn cleanly | Blow out, let it cool, snip the blob off and trim to 5mm | Only if it's heavy every burn: the candle is overwicked |
| Black smoke, soot on the glass | Incomplete burning: the flame is too tall, or being pushed about by a draught | Trim to 5mm and move it out of the draught | If it smokes even when trimmed and still |
| A tall, flickering flame | Wick too long, or a draught | Trim; keep it away from windows, fans and vents | If the flame stays very tall after trimming |
| Flame shrinks and goes out; wick sits in a pool of wax (drowning) | The melt pool is too deep for a short wick, so it floods | Pour or blot off some liquid wax, relight, burn with the wick trimmed | If it happens every time: the wick is too small |
| Wick bends over into the wax | The wick isn't trimming itself as it burns (bridging) | Snuff it, straighten it with a wick dipper while the wax is soft, trim | Often: the wrong wick for that wax and scent |
Causes from Candle Shack's troubleshooting pages on mushrooming, sooting and flames going out. Candle Shack is a UK candle-making supplier. The 5mm trim is from Living Light's candle care page.
Why does my candle wick mushroom?
Mushrooming is a cap of carbon on the end of the wick. Candle Shack explains it as "incomplete combustion of the wax and fragrance oil": the wick is delivering more fuel than there's oxygen to burn, and the leftover carbon builds up. A small amount is normal. Candle Shack says minor clubbing "is very common" and can't usually be avoided completely in strongly scented candles.
What makes it worse is a long wick, because a longer wick draws more fuel. Heavy mushrooming on every burn, even with the wick trimmed, is what Candle Shack calls "often a sign that a candle is overwicked", meaning the maker put in a bigger wick than the candle needed.
How do you fix a mushroomed wick?
How to fix a mushroomed candle wick
- Put the candle out
Use a snuffer or blow gently. The National Candle Association says not to use water, which makes hot wax spit.
- Let it cool
Wait until the wax has set. Trimming into a pool of hot wax drops the black bits in, and they act as extra wicks next time.
- Snip off the carbon cap
Use wick trimmers or nail scissors and cut just below the black blob. Pinching it off with a tissue works on a soft cap.
- Trim to 5mm
Living Light says to keep the wick trimmed to 5mm, and that trimming is best done before and during burning. The NCA says ¼ inch, which is about 6mm.
- Clear the debris
Lift any bits of wick, matches or dust out of the wax. Living Light says to clear wick debris away every time.
- Relight and watch it
A healthy flame is steady, teardrop-shaped and not smoking. If the cap comes back heavily within the hour, the wick is too big for that candle.
Why does my candle keep going out?
Usually the wick is drowning. The flame needs fuel, oxygen and heat, and Candle Shack lists the ways one of them gets cut off. The wick may be too short to stand above a deep pool of wax. It may bend over into the pool. The fragrance or colour in the wax may clog it. Or a draught may steal the heat. Drowning is the common one, especially after a candle has been trimmed too short.
- Too much liquid wax. Blow it out, tip a little of the melted wax into a paper towel in the bin (never the sink), then relight. Blotting with a folded paper towel works too.
- Wick trimmed too short. Let the wax set, then dig away a little wax around the wick with a butter knife so more of it stands clear.
- Wick bent into the pool. Straighten it with a wick dipper or a metal skewer while the wax is soft. Candle Shack says a wick that keeps bending over "may bridge" because it's the wrong wick for that wax and scent.
- Draughts. Candle Shack says draughts can put a flame out "by removing the heat". The NCA says to keep candles away from open windows, fans and air vents.
- It goes out every time, with a small flame that shrinks. That's a wick too small for the candle, or one that's being clogged by the scent or colour. You can't fix that at home.
Why is my candle smoking?
Soot is unburnt carbon, the same thing as mushrooming, leaving the flame as smoke. Candle Shack says it happens "when the flame is disturbed, either by airflow, excess fuel delivery or poor wick posture". So the fix is the same: trim the wick to 5mm, and move the candle away from draughts. The NCA's own rule is to trim to ¼ inch "to prevent high flames and soot".
How big should a candle flame be?
Smaller than most people think. Candle Shack gives about 30–35mm as a typical flame for a 30cl jar candle and 25–30mm for a 20cl one. It says a flame can reach 75mm, but one that tall "would probably fail a sooting behaviour test" and a fire safety test too. If yours is well over a thumb's length after trimming, the candle is overwicked.
| Candle size | Typical flame height | What a much taller flame means |
|---|---|---|
| 20cl jar (about a small 200g candle) | 25–30mm | Wick too long: trim. Still tall after trimming: overwicked. |
| 30cl jar (about a 300g candle) | 30–35mm | Same: trim first, then judge. |
| Any size | 75mm | Candle Shack says this would probably fail soot and fire-safety tests. Put it out. |
Flame heights from Candle Shack's sooting troubleshooting page. A candle labelled 200g holds roughly 20cl of wax, but jars vary.
Is a bad wick a fault you can return in NZ?
It can be. Under the Consumer Guarantees Act, goods have to be of acceptable quality and fit for their normal purpose. A candle whose wick drowns or goes out on every burn even when you follow the care instructions, or one with the wick set badly off-centre, isn't doing what a candle is for. Take it back to the shop that sold it and ask for a repair, a replacement or a refund. Consumer Protection sets out the rights.
Mushrooming that a trim fixes, or a flame that smokes in a draught, isn't a fault. The first burn and how long you burn it matter just as much as the wick, and the full routine is in candle care.
Frequently asked questions
How do you stop a candle wick mushrooming?
Trim it to 5mm before every burn, as Living Light says, and snip off any black cap once the candle has cooled. A long wick draws more fuel than the flame can burn, and the leftover carbon builds up as a mushroom. If it comes back heavily every time even when trimmed, the candle is overwicked and that's down to the maker.
What causes candle wick mushrooming?
Incomplete burning. Candle Shack, a UK candle supplier, explains that mushrooming happens when the wick delivers more wax and fragrance oil than there is oxygen to burn, leaving carbon on the wick. A little is normal in strongly scented candles. A lot usually means the wick is too long or too big for the candle.
How do you fix a candle that won't stay lit?
Blow it out, pour or blot off some of the liquid wax with a paper towel, make sure the wick stands clear of the wax and isn't bent over, and relight it away from draughts. If it still goes out on every burn, the wick is too small for the candle, which is a fault you can take back to the shop.
Why does my candle produce black smoke?
The flame is burning incompletely, usually because the wick is too long or a draught is pushing the flame about. The National Candle Association says to trim the wick to ¼ inch before each use to prevent high flames and soot. Move the candle away from windows, fans and vents.
How long should a candle wick be?
About 5mm. Living Light, a New Zealand candle maker, says to keep wicks trimmed to 5mm, before and during burning. The National Candle Association says ¼ inch, which is about 6mm. Trim it before every burn, not just the first one.
Sources
- Living Light Candles — candle care — last checked 15 September 2026
- National Candle Association — fire safety and candles — last checked 15 September 2026
- Candle Shack (UK candle supplier) — troubleshooting mushrooming (incomplete combustion, overwicking, minor clubbing is common) — last checked 2 November 2026
- Candle Shack (UK candle supplier) — troubleshooting sooting (flame heights for 20cl and 30cl candles) — last checked 2 November 2026
- Candle Shack (UK candle supplier) — reasons why a candle flame might go out (bridging, drowned wick, draughts, fragrance) — last checked 2 November 2026
- Consumer Protection (MBIE) — your rights under New Zealand consumer law — last checked 15 September 2026